Monday, 13 May 2013

OAuth 2 attacks - Introducing 'The Devil Wears Prada' and 'Lassie Come Home'

As the OAuth 2 framework is becoming more and more used I thought it would be useful to share some of the most common attacks. It is important to highlight that the attacks I am going to introduce today are not issues in the specification per se but rather possible implementation issues. The first document to look at when you try to secure one OAuth 2 implementation is the OAuth 2.0 Threat Model but this is way not enough. In order to have a safe implementation it is important to understand what is OAuth about and to be involved in the "OAuthsphere" (OAuth mailing list, blogs, etc),

In this blog post I will try to show two of the most common attacks that I have renamed  'The Devil Wears Prada' and 'Lassie Come Home'.

Let's see. Firstly the actors:

The Actors


The Devil Wears Prada

The first time I read about this potential issue was in one of John Bradley's blog post . This issue is also known as "confused deputy problem". In a nutshell (once again) OAuth is NOT an authentication protocol. It is an access delegation protocol. It is/can-be-used as an authentication protocol but only and only if you know what you are doing! Let's see what it could happen if you are using the OAuth Implicit Grant flow (aka Client side) . Firstly here a quick reminder of the Client side flow:

  

In the above example, Alice (the resource owner, RO from now) allows Bob  from www.printondemand,biz (the client)  to access the profile pictures from her Facebook (the server) account in order to have a nice photo album. So far so good, right? (Yes :)) Now let see what could happen if www.printondemand,biz would use the profile information of Alice to authenticate her:



The are at least two things to be noticed from the flow above:
  • www.printondemand.biz uses the profile information from Facebook to log in
  • www.printondemand.biz does not have any security. Indeed they have not Authenticated the User! (at all...)
What does this tell us? That www.printondemand.biz authenticates, given an Access Token.

Now let's see how we can use this information to "our" (from the attacker point of view) advantage.
Let's assume there is yet another client (www.dosomething.biz). This client uses legitimately the profile information from Alice to do something that Alice authorized for (e.g. keeping historical profile information). Now when Alice gives the Access Token to www.dosomething.biz the latter does exactly what Alice expects it to do. The problem is that he does as well something more, behind the back of Alice. Here's the flow:


So, referring to the image above, after point 6, Alice got from www.dosomething.biz what he requested. At this point Alice is out of the game. www.dosomething.biz owns an Access Token from Alice though. What www.dosomething.biz can do is to give this Access Token to www.printondemand.biz. And which one is the outcome? You have guessed it, right? How nice :) www.printondemand.biz just authenticated www.dosomething.biz as Alice!!!!
To be noticed that this attack came from something that the RO kind of trusted, hence I named it  "The Devil Wears Prada".

At this point you might wonder which one is the mitigation for this attack. There are several but the best that comes in my mind is to use OpenId Connect for authentication.

 Lassie Come Home

Ready for another one?  This attack is a generalization of on attack done some time ago against Facebook. Now let see an example:




The famous www.thecloudcompany.biz offers the possibility to register your own client.
One of the client of www.thecloudcompany.biz (named example) is one departement of www.thecloudcompany.biz itself. This clients runs under the domain of www.example.thecloudcompany.biz. Above you can see a normal client side flow.
The problem that can happens in this case is a bit subtle but well known. It is really important that the redirect uri matches as much as possible the hostname of the client. Let's see what it could happen if, at client registration time, www.example.thecloudcompany.biz chooses a redirect uri of *.thecloudcompany.biz


Following the image above let's assume that I (www.bad.com) have registered yet another client at thecloudcompany.biz. My client id is 'Bad' and ther registered redirect uri is www.bad.com.
The next step to do is to create a link as per the image above and let the RO click on it.
Guess where the RO Access Token ends up? If you answered www.bad.com kudos to you.
The reasons why this happens are basically two:

1. the registered redirect uri from the client 'example' is too loose so https://www.thecloudcompany.biz%2Foauth%2Fauthorize%3Fclient_id=Bad%26response_type=token%26redirect_uri=http://www.bad.com is a perfectly valid redirect uri!!
2. URL Fragment is preserved for 302 redirects

At this stage you might also wonder why I named this attack 'Lassie come home' but I also hope you figured out the answer :).
That's all for now folks. Happy hacking....




Wednesday, 1 May 2013

OAuth “dance” - server side flow

Getting some inspiration from this dialog about OAuth 1.0 I thought it would be nice to have something similar for OAuth 2.0


The Actors

 

The R.O. shows intent

Alice (R.O.): hey, Bob , I would like you to be able to access the profile pictures from my Facebook account so you can print for me a nice photo album.
Bob (client): no problem, I know how we can do it. All I need is you getting me an Authorization Code from Facebook.

The R.O. obtain an authorization code


Alice (R.O.): hey Mark, www.printondemand.biz wants an Authorization Code
Mark (server):
are you sure you want to give this code to www.printondemand.biz?
this will allow it to get all profile pictures from your profile.
Alice (R.O.):
yes it is ok.
Mark (server): ok I am sending you over to www.printondemand.biz

The R.O. is redirected to the client

Alice (R.O.): hey Bob here we go, this is the Authorization Code
Bob (client): thanks

The client exchange the Authorization Code for an
Access Token

Bob (client): hey Mark, I would like to trade my Authorization Code for an Access Token
Mark (server): hey Bob here we go

The client access the protected resource

Bob (client): hey Mark, give me the profile pictures, here is the
Access Token
Mark (server): here you are